ЁЯЪи KGMU UNDER SCRUTINY: Senior Professors Raise Serious Questions Over Alleged Favouritism, Examination Transparency and Gold Medal Selection in Plastic Surgery Department
A written representation dated November 18, 2026, submitted to the Dean, Faculty of Medicine, flags alleged preferential academic assistance, concerns over internal assessment procedures and examination confidentiality, and demands transparent Gold Medal criteria. Questions now arise over institutional accountability and the need for an independent investigation at one of Uttar Pradesh's premier medical universities.

Lucknow: Serious questions have been raised over the transparency, fairness and internal examination practices in the Department of Plastic Surgery at King George’s Medical University (KGMU), Lucknow, following a written complaint submitted to the Dean, Faculty of Medicine, on November 18, 2026. The complaint, signed by Prof. Brijesh Mishra and Prof. Divya Narain Upadhyaya, raises concerns regarding alleged preferential academic treatment, suspected examination-related irregularities, the handling of internal assessment marks and the absence of clearly communicated criteria for awarding the Gold Medal in Plastic Surgery.
The allegations, which concern the academic functioning of an important postgraduate medical department, have brought into focus a wider institutional question: how effectively are transparency, impartiality and accountability being maintained in academic assessment within a premier medical university?
The complaint seeks the Dean’s intervention and calls for a thorough and impartial examination of the issues raised. While the allegations require independent verification and should not be treated as established findings, the nature of the concerns makes a transparent institutional response particularly important.
Allegations of preferential academic treatment
One of the principal concerns raised in the complaint relates to alleged favouritism and preferential academic assistance extended towards a particular postgraduate resident in the Department of Plastic Surgery.
According to the complainants, suspicions have persisted for several months regarding the possibility of preferential academic support, including alleged private tutoring and possible advance communication of examination questions.
The complaint does not establish that examination questions were actually disclosed in advance. However, it argues that the possibility itself raises serious concerns about equal academic opportunity and the credibility of the examination process.
In a postgraduate medical education system, academic performance is expected to be assessed through consistent standards, equal access to educational resources and impartial evaluation. Any perception that one resident may be receiving preferential treatment can affect the confidence of other residents and faculty members in the fairness of the system.
The complainants have therefore sought independent verification of these concerns rather than allowing unresolved apprehensions to continue affecting the academic environment.
The issue is particularly significant because postgraduate medical examinations are not merely routine academic exercises. They contribute to the professional development, competence assessment and future careers of medical specialists. Maintaining equal standards for every resident is consequently essential.
Questions surrounding the preparation and handling of examination papers
Another important aspect of the complaint concerns the arrangements reportedly adopted by senior faculty members before an internal examination.
The letter states that, in view of prevailing apprehensions regarding examination confidentiality and fairness, two senior faculty members deliberately refrained from handing over their respective question papers to the Head of the Department before the internal examination.
According to the complaint, the faculty members independently prepared their question papers and subsequently evaluated the corresponding answer sheets.
The complainants describe this as a precautionary measure intended to preserve confidentiality and ensure that no postgraduate resident received an unfair advantage.
The circumstances described in the letter raise questions about the level of confidence among faculty members regarding examination-related procedures and the internal safeguards operating within the department.
If faculty members feel compelled to adopt separate arrangements to maintain examination confidentiality, it becomes important for the university administration to examine whether the existing procedures provide adequate safeguards and confidence to all concerned.
At the same time, the reasons behind these arrangements, their procedural validity and the actual examination practices would need to be independently examined before any conclusion is drawn.
The central concern is not simply who prepared a particular question paper, but whether the university has a sufficiently transparent and uniform mechanism to ensure that examination material remains confidential and that all candidates are assessed fairly.
Internal assessment process under scrutiny
Perhaps the most significant concern highlighted in the representation relates to the preparation and circulation of the consolidated internal assessment report.
According to the complaint, despite the direct involvement of faculty members in preparing question papers and evaluating answer sheets, the Head of the Department allegedly did not share the consolidated internal assessment report with the examining faculty members.
The letter further alleges that the consolidated assessment was prepared by the Head of the Department and subsequently shown directly to the postgraduate residents for their signatures.
The complainants state that the assessment was then forwarded without providing the concerned faculty members an opportunity to review or verify the final marks.
The complaint also expresses apprehension that the consolidated assessment may have been prepared in a manner favouring one particular resident.
These are serious allegations because internal assessment is an important component of postgraduate academic evaluation. Its credibility depends on the accuracy of marks, the participation of authorised examiners, the availability of supporting records and adherence to established university procedures.
Where several faculty members have participated in teaching, examination and evaluation, questions regarding their access to the final assessment record deserve appropriate administrative attention.
A transparent system should make it possible to establish how marks were compiled, who contributed to the assessment, who verified the final figures and whether the applicable academic regulations were followed.
The absence of a clear and verifiable assessment trail can create avoidable doubts, even where no wrongdoing has occurred.
For this reason, the concerns raised in the complaint warrant examination of the original assessment records, evaluation sheets, relevant communications and the procedure followed for finalising and forwarding the internal assessment.
Gold Medal selection criteria also questioned
The complaint raises another important issue concerning the award of the Gold Medal in Plastic Surgery.
The signatories have requested the Dean’s Office to formally clarify the criteria governing eligibility and selection for the prestigious academic distinction.
According to the representation, the eligibility requirements, evaluation parameters, relative weightage assigned to different assessments and procedure for determining the Gold Medal recipient should be clearly defined and communicated to faculty members and postgraduate residents.
The concern is significant because academic awards carry considerable professional and institutional value. They recognise merit, academic consistency and performance and may also influence the professional credentials of postgraduate medical graduates.
In the absence of clearly communicated criteria, even a legitimate selection process may become vulnerable to questions and perceptions of unequal treatment.
The complainants have emphasised that the Gold Medal should be awarded strictly on merit and in accordance with university regulations.
The university administration would therefore be expected to clarify the applicable rules, the assessment components considered, their respective weightage, the competent authority responsible for the final decision and the procedure available for resolving any discrepancies.
Such clarification would not only address the concerns expressed in the complaint but could also strengthen confidence in the award process across the department.
A larger institutional question for KGMU
The issues raised in the representation extend beyond an individual departmental disagreement. They concern the institutional responsibility of a university to maintain credible examination systems and ensure that academic decisions are supported by transparent procedures.
KGMU is a prominent medical university in Uttar Pradesh, and its academic standards carry significance for postgraduate medical education, professional training and public confidence in medical institutions.
For an institution of this standing, even allegations that have not yet been verified deserve a responsible and timely administrative response.
The credibility of a medical university is not determined solely by its infrastructure, clinical services, research achievements or academic reputation. It also depends on the fairness of its internal systems, the impartiality of its examinations and the confidence of its faculty members and students in institutional decision-making.
When concerns about examination confidentiality, internal assessment and academic recognition emerge together, the administration has an opportunity to demonstrate that established procedures are more important than individual positions or departmental influence.
The matter also raises a broader question about the availability of effective internal mechanisms through which faculty members can report concerns without creating unnecessary conflict within academic departments.
A healthy academic environment requires space for professional disagreement, scrutiny of administrative decisions and the independent participation of faculty members in academic processes.
If such concerns are left unanswered, uncertainty can affect departmental relationships, resident confidence and the wider perception of institutional fairness.
Demand for independent and impartial examination
In their representation, the two professors have requested urgent intervention by the Dean, Faculty of Medicine, to ensure that the matter is thoroughly and impartially investigated.
They have also specifically requested that the Head of the Department should not be allowed to moderate University Question Papers and that appropriate measures should be instituted to restore confidence in the examination system of the Department of Plastic Surgery.
The request places responsibility on the university administration to examine the allegations through an appropriate mechanism rather than relying exclusively on departmental explanations or informal assurances.
An impartial examination of the matter could include verification of the relevant question papers, examination records, answer sheets, internal assessment documents, faculty participation and the applicable rules governing academic evaluation.
The administration could also examine whether all concerned faculty members were provided the opportunity to review the consolidated assessment and whether the final marks were compiled and forwarded in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
Similarly, the criteria for the Plastic Surgery Gold Medal could be formally reviewed and communicated to remove uncertainty regarding eligibility and merit-based selection.
Any administrative or corrective action, if warranted, would naturally need to follow the applicable university regulations and established principles of fairness.
The importance of an institutional response
The complaint presents the university administration with an important opportunity to demonstrate its commitment to academic integrity.
A transparent response would require more than simply acknowledging receipt of a representation. The issues raised concern examination confidentiality, assessment procedures and academic recognition, all of which are central to the credibility of postgraduate education.
The university could consider establishing an independent fact-finding mechanism involving appropriate senior academic representatives who are not directly connected with the matters under examination.
It would also be important to provide all concerned individuals an opportunity to present their explanations and supporting records. The process should be confidential, impartial and based on verifiable evidence.
If the allegations are not substantiated, a clear explanation of the applicable procedures and findings could help restore confidence. If procedural shortcomings are identified, appropriate corrective measures could strengthen the system and prevent similar concerns in the future.
Equally important is the need for clearly documented examination and assessment protocols. These should establish responsibilities for question-paper preparation, confidentiality, evaluation, consolidation of marks, verification and final submission.
The Gold Medal selection process should also operate through clearly communicated and consistently applied eligibility and merit criteria.
Such safeguards would benefit not only the Department of Plastic Surgery but also the wider academic environment of the university.
Questions that deserve clear answers
The representation brings several questions into focus for the university administration:
Was the prescribed procedure followed in preparing, handling and safeguarding internal examination question papers?
Were all faculty members involved in assessment provided appropriate access to the consolidated internal assessment records?
Was the final assessment verified by the authorised faculty members and competent academic authorities?
Are the criteria and weightage for awarding the Plastic Surgery Gold Medal formally documented and communicated?
Have the concerns raised by the signatories been independently examined?
These questions do not constitute findings of misconduct. They identify areas where administrative clarification and verification would help protect the credibility of the academic system.
The university’s response, and the transparency with which it addresses the concerns, will be important in determining whether confidence can be restored among the faculty members and postgraduate residents concerned.
Conclusion: Academic credibility must remain above departmental interests
The allegations raised by the two senior faculty members underline the importance of institutional safeguards in postgraduate medical education.
No academic institution can afford to allow uncertainty surrounding examination confidentiality, internal assessment or merit-based recognition to persist without an appropriate examination of the facts.
At the same time, allegations must be investigated fairly, and no individual should be judged without an opportunity to respond.
For KGMU, the immediate priority should be to ensure that the concerns are examined independently, the relevant academic records are verified and the applicable rules are followed without favour or prejudice.
The larger issue is one of institutional confidence. Students and residents must be able to trust that their academic performance will be assessed impartially. Faculty members must have confidence that their academic contributions will be recognised and that examination procedures will be followed consistently.
The representation dated November 18, 2026, has brought these concerns formally before the university administration. The responsibility now rests with the competent authorities to examine the matter and communicate an appropriate response.
Ultimately, the reputation of a premier medical university is strengthened not by avoiding difficult questions, but by addressing them transparently, fairly and decisively.
Academic merit must remain the foundation of recognition, examination integrity the foundation of evaluation, and institutional accountability the foundation of public trust.
Editorial clarification: This report is based on the written representation dated November 18, 2026, supplied for publication. The allegations have not been independently established through this document. The views and claims are attributed to the complainants. The responses of the persons concerned and the university administration were not included in the supplied material. All concerned parties should be offered an opportunity to present their version before publication.
рддрд╛рдЬрд╝рд╛ рдЦрдмрд░реЗрдВ рд╕рдмрд╕реЗ рдкрд╣рд▓реЗ рдкрд╛рдПрдВ
WhatsApp Channel, Google News рдФрд░ рд╕реЛрд╢рд▓ рдореАрдбрд┐рдпрд╛ рдкрд░ рдлреЙрд▓реЛ рдХрд░реЗрдВ



